How to Compare Moving Companies Side by Side
Five steps to compare moving quotes the right way and spot the patterns that signal trouble.
Comparing moving companies is harder than it should be. Quotes use different structures. Inclusions vary. Some movers do not even do the move themselves. Here is a systematic way to compare offers and pick the right one for your job.
Step 1: Same scope, every time
Before you compare anything, make sure each mover is quoting the same job. Give every company the same information:
- Pickup address and destination address
- Date and time flexibility
- Same inventory list (room by room)
- Specialty items (piano, safe, fragile art)
- Access details (stairs, elevators, parking, COI needed)
- What you are doing yourself (packing, disassembly)
- What you want the mover to do
If two movers are quoting different scope, the quotes are not comparable.
Step 2: Verify the basics
Before getting deeper into comparison, run each company through a quick verification:
- ✓ License numbers. PA PUC number for intrastate PA moves; USDOT and MC numbers for interstate. Verify them at safer.fmcsa.dot.gov.
- ✓ Insurance. Ask for proof of general liability, auto liability, and workers’ compensation.
- ✓ Physical address. A real warehouse or office, not a P.O. box.
- ✓ Reviews. Across multiple platforms: Google, BBB, Yelp.
- ✓ Broker vs carrier. Ask if they will perform the move themselves or subcontract it.
Step 3: Build a comparison sheet
Put each quote side by side. Track these fields:
Crew size and truck size
Hourly rate or total binding price
Minimum hours (and how travel time counts)
What’s included: blankets, dollies, basic valuation, etc.
What’s billed separately: materials, packing labor, fuel, COI
Valuation level (released-value vs full-value)
Estimate type (binding, not-to-exceed, non-binding)
Estimated total, not just hourly rate
Step 4: Look beyond price
Once two or three companies are within a reasonable price range, the right answer often is not the cheapest. Consider:
How easy was it to get the quote?
If they were responsive, on time, and answered questions thoroughly, that pattern usually continues into the move itself. If they were slow, vague, or pushy, that is a signal.
Did they do an in-home or video survey?
Movers who quote sight-unseen are guessing. Movers who survey are committing to a number based on what they have actually seen.
Are they employees or day labor?
Companies with employees (W-2, trained, repeat crews) deliver more consistent quality than companies that scramble for day labor each morning. Ask the question.
What is the claims process like?
If something gets damaged, what happens? Ask each company. The answer reveals a lot about their priorities.
Step 5: Watch for these patterns
The lowball + add-on pattern
An unusually low quote attracts you. On move day, accessorial charges pile up: “long carry fees,” “stair fees,” “additional materials.” The final bill is well above the original quote and well above what other movers quoted.
The broker pattern
A company quotes a great price online, takes a deposit, then assigns the job to a different company who shows up. That company has no commitment to the original quote.
The deposit-demand pattern
A legitimate mover may require a small deposit to hold a date. Demanding a large cash deposit upfront is a red flag, especially before a survey.
When the lowest quote is right
Sometimes the cheapest quote really is the best deal. Indicators:
- The mover is fully licensed and insured
- The estimate is in writing with itemized inclusions
- Reviews across multiple platforms are consistent and positive
- They did a proper survey
- The crew size and truck size match the job
- They are transparent about what is and is not included
If all of those check out and the price is still lower, you may have found a well-run mover with efficient operations. If any of them are missing, ask why before you sign.
Related Resources
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I compare moving companies fairly?
Get the same scope of work quoted by each mover. Same pickup address, same destination, same inventory, same valuation level, same date range. Then compare apples to apples on price, crew size, truck size, what is included, and what is billed separately. A lower hourly rate with a smaller crew often costs more in total than a higher rate with the right-sized crew.
Should I get three quotes or more?
Three is the sweet spot for most moves. It gives you enough range to spot outliers without consuming days of your time. For interstate or high-value moves, four to five quotes is reasonable. For very small or simple local jobs, two careful quotes from licensed movers are often enough.
What is the most important factor in comparing movers?
Licensing and insurance, then crew quality, then price. A licensed and insured mover with positive reviews and a clear written estimate is worth more than the cheapest quote from an unverifiable company. Most moving horror stories trace back to choosing on price alone.
How do I know if a moving quote is too low?
Compare it to the median of the quotes you receive. If one quote is 30-40% below the others, ask why. Sometimes the answer is legitimate (smaller crew, fewer included services). Often the answer reveals a problem (the mover plans to add charges on move day, or is not properly licensed). Lowest quote is not always the best deal.
Do brokers count as moving companies?
No. Moving brokers sell your job to a carrier who actually does the move. Brokers are not the same as the company doing the work. Always confirm that the company you are hiring will physically perform the move with their own employees and trucks, not subcontract it to whoever is available that day. Ask the question directly.
Ready to Get Moving?
Tell us your dates and we’ll handle the rest. Free, no-pressure quote.
LiteMovers · PA PUC A-8916211 · USDOT 2173383 · MC-888055 · Serving Greater Philadelphia since 2007.
Comments are closed.